Sunday School and Lessons Learned
70All this talk about religion reminded me of a peculiar story from my time at Sunday School. I've fond memories of it (while it lasted) and though it ended rather abruptly, I learned some very valuable lessons early on in life. If you want to know what lessons these may be, scroll down to the bottom and you can be done with this hub. If you, however, want to know how I came by the knowledge, read on.
Walking on Water
When I was 7 or 8, I attended Sunday School as I was supposed to –it's not the norm anymore but back then all kids in Spain went to prepare for the First Communion. I had fun, too, the stories about Jesus and the Apostles were pretty and entertaining, much as the bedtime stories my granddad told me at night. At that age, I didn't have any preconceived notions about religion –my grandparents were practicing Catholics, and they took me to church every now and then. No biggie there.
Anyhow, all was well in Sunday School until that fatidic day when we came to the parable of Jesus walking on water. It was a life time ago, but I remember as clear as water (the very same where Jesus supposedly walked on) that I raised my hand to check whether I had heard right...
Mind you, raising my hand was brave of me, at that tender age I was rather scared of priests and nuns, they seemed creepy to my childish eyes, those blacker than black garments, and that straight-backed rigidity all the time... but I digress. Here I was, raising my hand...
Me: Excuse me, father, did you say Jesus walked on the water?
Father: Yes, child.
Me: How come? How could he do that? People cannot do that.
Father: Well, not normal people, but Jesus the son of God could.
Me: Sorry, father, I don't understand. Anyone trying to do that would just go under, it is not possible to walk on water!
Father: Child, it is possible, Jesus did it.
Me: No.
Father: Yes, it was a miracle, you must believe it.
At this point, I was rather agitated, as were my class mates, never mind the good father, who I guess could see he had a "faith mutiny" in his hands. To be honest, even though I questioned the miracle, I actually wanted to believe such a wondrous thing was possible –much as I wanted to believe Superman existed and would save me from harm, but I just couldn't wrap my little (but apparently inquiring) mind around the idea that this was possible.
Me: He would drown. (Big pout.)
Father: Child, you must have faith to believe it. (Stern, scloding voice, severe posture, condemning look: my first brush with fire and brimstone.)
Me: You're just saying so, I don't believe it! (I can remember my exact words, but something along these lines. I also remember I was past agitation at that point, I was actually mad that a priest would be telling lies! I got significant slaps on the wrist every time I was caught lying!)
Father: You are dismissed from class, wait outside to see me after the hour is over.
Well, I didn't wait around to get a verbal spank, as soon as other classes where dismissed I took off with friends. Whoops!
Heading Home To Face The Music
On the way home I started to think about the repercussions, mostly on account of having been kicked out, but I also had serious second thoughts about arguing with the father AND not having stuck around for a second round --as I'd been told!
I arrived home rather distressed and blurted my way through the whole story to my mother, who still today tells the tale unable to contain hysteric peels of laughter. She says she was half mystified by my need to have proof even then, and half undone by motherly love (ahem) at my horrified and shuddering recount of the entire business.
At the time, though, she tried to do "the right thing", which the dear father had been incapable of (then again, maybe I didn't let him, since I took off after class, but allow me to fancy a wild guess that I wouldn't have got a pat on the back for my efforts), and explained to me that there are things you can see and others that you can't, it's a matter of believing them, and this is called faith. And, she told me, some people believe these things and it's OK to do so.
I put the whole thing aside, mostly because I was relieved I hadn't gotten a big dress down from mom, but also because I figure my attention span was as it's supposed to be at 7 or 8! Now, my attention returned to the topic at hand quick smart as soon as dad got home from work, and I could "feel" my mother telling him my pitfall from grace. As I dreadfully expected, dad called me to have this little tete-a-tete.
The Seeds of Toletance ... in the Name of the Father
Dad: What's this I hear about you arguing with Father X on account of Jesus walking on water?
Me (pouty, but quite ready to be verbally spanked, I didn't much see a way out this time around): Well, he told this story and I don't think it's possible, I don't believe it.
Dad: Daughter, it's OK. Tell me why you don't believe it.
Me: Just as I told Father X, I've never seen this and when people get into the sea or the swimming pool they go down under, it's not possible TO WALK ON WATER! (Near tears here, I think I was half scared of, oh, I don't know, being sent to my room without dinner or something, and half frustrated out of my mind that any adult would believe such an outlandish thing was possible!)
Dad: Right, makes sense. What do you want to do about Sunday School? (this question asked to my 7 or 8 year old self) You still want to go? If so, I'll take you and talk to Father X
Me (big round eyes): I don’t want to go anymore, dad.
Dad: It's OK if you want to go, I can go with you and explain.
Me: I don't want to go, it's silly! (Now picture me here as a little self righteous monster! I probably also stomped my foot on the floor for good measure!)
Dad (raised eyebrows, stern look): Now, quit that attitude right this minute. It's OK for you not to believe that story, but it doesn't mean it's silly, and it doesn't mean it's not true, either.
I may have been a brat, but I wasn't a stupid brat! That was my cue to leave well enough alone and take off to greener pastures, which at the time probably involved running wild with my bike or something equally, well, kid-like.
And thus ended my Sunday School foray, together with my innocence regarding stomping my foot on the floor about beliefs. Needless to say, I never took First Communion. Easy to say today, but I was the only kid in the neighborhood, the entire school, and my entire family that didn't. Talk about convictions!
THE LESSONS!
Figure what, there's a moral to this story! I may have been a brat, but I learned a few valuable lessons:
Lesson 1: Faith it's a personal choice, and in that way, it's undisputable. Check.
Lesson 2: Consequently, everyone has a right to their beliefs. Or lack of thereof. Check.
Lesson 3: If you dispute faith to a believer, you may get in trouble. And rightly so, it turns out, because they know as much as you do on the topic. Check.
Lesson 4: Some adults listen to dissenting opinions. When they do, it's extremely wise not to stomp one's foot on the floor, and even wiser to be thankful that they're listening. Check.
These lessons have remained with me until today. Now I know that tolerance lays in not stomping one's foot on the floor, fundamentally. Today, when I hear "All things are possible to those who believe", I can't help but remember the parable of Jesus walking on water, and rather fondly, too.
CommentsLoading...
Elena, you and I shared an ailment in common as children; not accepting everything we were told by adults as gospel.
I like this because it addresses that issue that lies at the crux of the problem with organized religion; the insistence that this, that or the other faith is the only truth and that everyone MUST accept it, or else! Nicely done.
I went to sunday school every summer when I was shipped off to my maternal grand parents during summer school break. I can honestly say I don't remember a thing about it. I basically ignored the whole thing I guess. Apparently I didn't even consider it worth contesting.
My confrontations began with the advent of T.V. That's when I started warning everyone about the "Advertising Industry" as I called it. It's been going on ever since.
Your inquisitive mind is your greatest treasure. Never surrender.
It is my great pleasure to be here. I believe we share a very similar philosophy and the desire for a world of Peace and unity. To put it plainly, we are family.
Hi Elena,
I loved your hub, and it brought back memories of my own Sunday School lessons. I always enjoyed stories, and to my mind, many of the tales I heard at Sunday School were right up there with Cinderella and Snow White. Just as improbable, but still interesting and exciting. I obviously wasn't possessed of the power of analysis at that age! It's strange that as time has gone on I look back on my early church-going career with a sense of nostalgia. Take aside the unlikely content of much of the Bible, the love thy neighbour message is a good one, and I would be so pleased if it were widely practised. We can only live in hope!
Great hub, Elena!
After reading your hub, I remember a similar story by a colleague when she was of the same age as you. It was about the statue of Baby Jesus at this friend's altar. Everything about Baby Jesus being God, she said she believed. One day, however, she got curious about the statue and touched it. By force of "bad luck" or her clumsines, the statue fell off her hands and broke. The breaking of the statue was, for her, a crisis of faith. "What a lie that God is in that altar. Why would the statue break just like that?"
Believing that the statue was Jesus was a big lie, she recalls now. That time, she took the dismantled head of the statue and went around playing with it. This scandalized so much her parents and the entire neighborhood that a ritual had to be done to rid her of the "evil force" inside her young head. Surely, she learned a lot from recalling such experience.
Sorry, this is a long comment but I can't help not sharing this story with you.
Excellent !!! Love it..
I love this. Great. Every drop.
From a creative stand point, I was right there with you. You were cute as a little girl. From a morality stand point, perfect. I love your ideology.
You've done well to observe, process, and understand that differences don't divide. They define.
Namaste, my dear Elena. K@ri sends her love!













Pam Roberson 3 years ago
Elena, thank you for sharing your personal experience AND for bringing out some very important lessons about faith and religion! Faith is a personal choice, and everyone has a right to believe what they want to believe. :)
I'll bet your parents were so proud of you for not being afraid to question something that made no logical sense. Isn't it funny how we can remember those profound moments so vividly many many years down the road? :)
Great hub, and I'm anxious to continue reading your others!