A Love Letter
82
Dearest,
It's been so long. I don't know where to start. The beginning would seem the best place, but the beginning of what? We met, became friends, and then you left and were gone. Not all so sudden nor so simple, but it feels that way after all these years, time has a way to disrobe facts of all embellishments and leave reality bare.
Let me get this off my chest first thing, if I don't get it out right away I won't be able to say all the other things I want to say: I could act innocent and say I had no idea, but of course I did. I just refused to acknowledge what couldn't be, and wasn't my problem, and preferred to play along from a place that was comfortable for me. I knew then it couldn't have been comfortable for you, I knew, but I still played along because it was easier and safe. Please, forgive me for that.
There is so much I want to tell you. There are so many things that I need you to know, bleed for you to know... After all these years it's selfish of me to burden you with all of it, but at least this time I'm thinking of you, of what you'll feel when you read my letter. I can only hope you will feel something...
I need you to know I cried an ocean, I shed tears that I couldn't explain, not back then. I cried so much at the loss, but I couldn't say what had me torn, not even to myself, not really. You left and took away the light and the laughter, and I could do nothing to stop it, because you never told me how you felt. Forgive me for never allowing you to. I never gave you a cue, though I knew, I knew. But I didn't want to listen then. You were so right all those years ago. I didn't want to hear it.
Forgive me for driving you away, and then missing you, and then blaming you for leaving. What could I have done, back then? What could we have done? You loved me and I couldn't, not then.
Your leaving was an awakening of sorts –I don't know if I have to thank you for that, I know I hated you then, selfishly and absurdly, because I wasn't in a place where I could have, would have, acknowledged that I missed you, that you where the light I wanted to absorb, the sun that warmed me even when I didn't know that I was cold. It took you vanishing from my life to understand that the light had gone out.
I can't honestly say that cold overcame me, not right then, I had a good life, I had it all, really, but your leaving caused a chasm, a gulf that I didn't understand, didn't want to understand, and didn't want to navigate, it forced me to swim upstream, and I had no use for that back then. So long ago.... It still terrifies me, the notion of swimming upstream.
I'm not sorry that you loved me, I couldn't help that, but I'm sorry that I never said anything, did anything to prevent the cloak of invisibility from driving you away. Maybe that was for the best. You went away hurt but ready to move on. I never did move on, though, I feel I'm still at the bend where we parted, still missing you like the day you left. I feel I've lost so much along the way, your friendship, your laughter, your consistency. I lost all that when I lost you.
I hope beyond hope that you'll forgive me, for the pain I caused you then, and for being so selfish to burden you with all of this now. I must, I can't help it. After all these years I'm finally in a place where I can write and tell you that I miss you. I never stopped missing you.
I hope you are happy today, I hope you can forgive me. Please write, even if it's only to say goodbye again. I need to move on, too.
With all my love.
CommentsLoading...
Gulp. I hope that whoever this is about gets the chance to read it -- it deserves to be read. What a lovely heart you have, mujer.
How come it always seems easy to walk away and then be haunted after a couple of steps?
So we should stay tuned for next week's episode, eh? This is better than a telenovela!
Elena--it's BEAUTIFUL!!!
Sweet dreams!
That's a tough question, though. Between the two letters, volumes have been spoken. Would a response really hasten the moving on, or continue the pain? But without a response, how the reader feels about your soul being placed in the open is left only to the writer's imagination.
You are such a talented and emotional writer, that only you would be able to come up with the words that are still left unspoken between the two, because I cannot think of any......
Thanks for the tissue, by the way!
I love this hub. It is so sad though to know that you are hurting so deeply.
Do you want to know a story? My fiance that died so many years ago told me that his first wife Jennifer was the first love of his life. He didn't know it all that much back then. He knew he loved her but he was young and stupid. He treated her bad and cheated. She loved him and put up with it for a long time until she moved on and left him.
It took him many years of suffering and sadness. Guilt and lonlieness until he met me. He said I was so much like her and a good girl. He promised me I was his second chance to be the man he should have been with her. We set out to find her and for him to apologize to her for what he did. He wanted her forgiveness. He always told me I helped him, unfortunately he died without having the chance to say almost the very words that your HUB describes.
I searched for her for many years after his death and I actually found her. I told her all he told me. And although she was sad to hear of his death she felt that her love she had for him all those years were not in vain. And I was able to finish what he wasn't able to do. Apologize. We are now good friends.......
Sometimes it takes losing the one we loved to realize how much they really mean to us.....
Wow....great hub Elena and equally great addition at the end jjrubio! That was an incredible thing you did, making sure his ex knew how he felt. I really admire you for that.
thanks KCC...I felt that it was something I HAD TO DO... through my faith in GOD I beleive I will see him again one day and how could I look him in the eye and tell him I didn't keep my promise. ( when he died he was in a coma for 6 days...I talked to him even though he couldn't hear me but I said I would do all the things he needed to do for him as a promise) He had so much left to accomplish and he wasn't able to. I am proud to say that alot I do now in my life is for him. And I think he would be proud of me.
That's awesome, jjrubio! You're a tough lady, and I admire you.
thanks...that means alot.
Hey Leni! If you don't follow up I'm going to have to hate you. And THIS time I mean it! You have been warned! LOL
I'm writing this through tears. Beautiful! This hub reads like something Francesca would've written to her photographer in "Bridges of Madison County". You *will* tell us how this turns out, right? Not keep us in suspense? Good or bad, I'll be laying in a supply of Kleenex.
Elena, a think a poll IS in order! Will they or won't they meet again? Should they even try??
OMG!!! I shared this at my facebook...I hope that is ok...I am so choked up! I ahve to say NOTHING has hit so close to home as this!
** edit** i re read it...sobbing now! Thanks a lot!
**edit again** I cant read this again.
So you've decided, Elena. For now......
Okay, this Hub has ripped my soul apart, put it back together...and left me feeling naked and vulnerable...OUTSTANDING!!!! ( to see me naked is outstanding of course)
See, now I have to commit one way or the other. I just can't decide.
The writer will be tortured, I think if she doesn't know the reader's reaction to her apology. But it will drag things out for her, and she is obviously already hurting over her past decisions.
Dang!! I'm going to have to think about it and come back!
By the way, your email last night was so sweet. Thank you!
I am a selfish SOB... I want to know the reaction right away. especially to this ... if you throw your heart out to be picked at then a response would be appropriate...My son says "that is deep man"
We Americans tend to like a happy ending. I think the unanswered love letter is sadly delicious though.
Pain does build character. I have caused so much pain...Here I go... I was in Iraq...the lives i took..poets, dreamers, husbands and fathers. the pain is real, the pain... I am dead. My humor is all I have. I wonder what those families would say to me? A killer, a murderer... sigh I cry a lot
Okay, so I'll commit to.......there should be a response. But I don't know that the reader would really want to.
See, I'm back on the fence again. Who'd have thought these hubs would have me so emotional? You are exactly right with the comfortable part in your last comment.
I am off to write a hub on this...I dont want to jack this beautiful Hub here.
Randy--ain't it the truth? I LOVE the movie "Message in a Bottle", but the ending just tears me up EVERY TIME!! I hollar at the TV everytime to not take the last bottle out. But there really wouldn't be closure otherwise, would there?
Pest--the whole Iraq thing. Check your email in a little while.
Damn we love a good soap opera now don't we? "Tune in next time..."
This was a great hub though Elena. Once again. Although I like to think this isn't neccessarily a letter written to any one "person." I like to think this is someone saying goodbye to their own innocence. What a wonderfully terrible letter this would be!
"I need you to know I cried an ocean, I shed tears that I couldn't explain, not back then. I cried so much at the loss, but I couldn't say what had me torn, not even to myself, not really. You left and took away the light and the laughter, and I could do nothing to stop it..."
Oh bring back my sweet innocence!!
"Forgive me for driving you away, and then missing you, and then blaming you for leaving. What could I have done, back then?"
Damn the road to maturity is a bumpy one. An uphill battle for sure. Thanks for the Kleenex though. Always thinking about the needs of others. So nice.
"True love is when you love something more than yourself..."
PM...okay..My dumb Hub is posted :rolleyes;
Dammit...I am trying to watch NASCAR! ...
Elena - maybe off target here but who is to know if the recipient will actually read the letter (unless that is a given here)- but what if after that person reads and then decides to answer in either a negative or positive manner; how will this affect the letter writers? what long term effect will this have on them? a positve or negative answer - it makes no difference if contact is made when maybe the other person has finally got over the letter writer & is settled and happy at last.
...it could possibly be another instant solution in the *now* with longterm painful effects coming back to haunt them *later* - plus if one person has never got over the other but has managed in spite of all those old feelings of unrequited love - to build a new life with a new person - and that is then screwed up again.......How would the initiator of the letters feel?
all these questions but no answers (which I guess is what this all about!) - I go with "don't expect an answer to the letter" as the person from long ago could have changed radically and is maybe no longer the idealised person who could be loved as much today....too much water under the bridge ....take care Elena ....cheers
hope i am not pulling the tone down! i just think there are times you just cannot go back, much and all as you may want to...beautiful, passionate and thought provoking writing as always...
Elena--I can't read the whole question for the poll. I took a guess at how you were wording it and voted likewise.
Pulling the tone down?!?!! ajcor--you're right there with us!! You make some excellent points!
Pest--my NASCAR got changed to iCarly when the guys left for the feed store. Oh well. I'm too into this letter to really care, anyway.....
dammit PM! I love you to tears! no NASCAR your way either??? well the hell with everything then! Between this Hub and the shit I just posted...I am a flippin mess! snot and tears... WTF????
Did you expect all of this when you wrote it, Elena?
thank you Elena! - I will wait for the outcome of this love lost dilemma!....cheers
Sorry. I should have said, "Did you expect all of this when you PUBLISHED it?"!!!!
thank-you also to Proud Mom for your comment ....
such a moving letter, touches the heart deeply, tears streaming down my face...memories of painful times and a deep love that lives forever in my heart...my husband who is the love of my life and still by my side. Perhaps I will write him a love letter as a demonstration of my realizations and deep love for him.
Thank you for posting this!
"So much better writing it when the love is there than when it isn't."
You should write for Hallmark.... :-))
Well of course, Elena!! I spend quite a bit on Hallmark. I have the stuff to make my own, but I can't ever come up with the great sayings. Maybe I just need to hit you up!!
Hola Elena,
I now know what happened, cold or no response was from your side not his. As I said in my previous comment & you realize too that life goes on.
~ Our eyes are placed in front because it is more important to look ahead than to look back. ~
Buena suerte
You should write love songs. Great hub!
Hola Elena,
What do you mean? This is not about me. I am lost now. Do you mean it's just your creation. Well if it is so then it feels very real.
Man, this is so beautiful. Thanks for being able to express your thoughts in such a meaningful way.
ohhh its hurting.....really amazing....its heart melting...after reading this letter anyone can come back.i dont have words to say.thanx for sharing...
A love lost and an unrequited love are two of the more painful things than death itself. Thanks for exposing your heart like this, nothing is more passionate.
I know, I'm also big on catharsis! LOL Well now, a very personal and open letter to hubbers should be great. :D
Elena! This is so overwhelmingly beautiful!
I haven't had a chance to read all of your comments, but in one of them you say, "...the question is if they are rightly left unspoken or if it'd be better to speak them, for the sake of closure."
My vote is SPEAK! Unfinished business, to me, is one of those things that can really weigh down a person's soul. It's the makings of sleepless nights. If there's a chance to talk through the past with someone with whom I've shared an experience that was left unfinished, I am always grateful. And I have too many of those experiences to share in a comment, but each one of those opportunities opened my eyes whether it resulted in me hearing what I wanted to hear or not. Sometimes it resulted in both of us walking away and knowing it was always never meant to be (friendship, love, etc.), but at least there were no questions about how we felt then and now.
You've really outdone yourself this time! Oh, and I've used up all of your tissues. ;)
Great writing great hub. I detect some true feelings under the soap opera. When My ex left she wrote me long letter which was a catalogue of everything I ever did wrong in 34 years. Talk about remembering and harbouring every event. She either wrote it all down or never forgot. Not a word about what she did or why. Trivial things like working late or a joking comment at a party were were on the list. go figure.
What a lovely letter. Thanks for the Kleenex. *cry*
This sort of crap seems to be happenning more and more on Hubpages!! It must come to end dammit!
I missed it! Someone flagged your hub as a duplicate to someone else's? I'm very sorry to hear that, Elena. Did you find the duplicate? I'm going to go look....
Elena, do you have a blog? I found this letter posted on a blog signed "Elena".
I already emailed it to you, Elena. It looks like a woman's blog, but I can't really tell for sure.
that is BS... I posted my poem I wrote like 6 years ago and some other people were using it on other websites...( I am guessing they saw it via my old myspace blog) but mine was flagged for duplicate too. I fought it and wrote hub pages over and over and showed them the facts and the links to the other sights and told them I wrote it back in 2002.... they removed the flag and all is better.
fight it...this is YOUR HUB and no one elses. Don't let someone have it without a fight.
But they signed YOUR NAME to it. That should be a hint to HP right there!
I hope it all works out for you ( in your favor ofcourse!) Just remember, imitation is a form of flattery....so copying your hub was a way of saying the hub was a good one!!! even if it is ethically wrong to copy and it sure pisses me off...=)
Could be. Where this one ends with, "All My Love,", they've added, "Elena" as if the letter was from you. If you don't get the email soon, let me know. I could post it on facebook.
You're angry and hurt for what this person has done. Even if they meant it as a compliment, they didn't ask your permission or give you the proper credit. That has got to be frustrating. I am frustrated that people just can't be honest. What would it have hurt to publish the link that they got it from? Dishonesty is one of those things that will set me off like nothing else! But please don't let this be the end of your creativity in this beautiful love story! We've been drawn into it, and are pining to find out what happens next!!
THAT'S WONDERFUL!!!!!!
I think we should celebrate!
Elena~ That was probably something any one of us wishes we would /could write to somebody from our past. It was beautiful! Now I'm off to read the 'not a love letter' so I can feel like I know what I'm talking about!
Elena Glad you got that sorted out. Justice is done.
very nice.
This was a very touching and beautiful letter. Honestly I do not think you should feel guilty if you pushed your ex away, or if your feelings were not as strong. In many relationships one person often feels more strongly than the other, so there is nothing wrong with that. Very beautiful letter.
Phew! Glad I was reading a "Certified Original" hub, and not a knock-off! (Seriously, though, glad you got that sorted out.)
Very creative and good of you! You are doing what the best writers do!
Elena, the poll is showing heavy favor for a response. Being from the microwave generation, I'm anxious to find out what happens next. 2 years would just KILL me! So what do we do to help get your red banner removed? :-)
Made me think about how over thirty years ago, I should just mailed that love letter I wrote and tore up. I would love again, but will never know why I let him walk away without knowing and without trying. Great hub!
WOW Elena this is really one outstanding piece of art! It brings some memories of my own flowing back .. LOL.. This is really great and i hope that you made up your mind concerning the reply LETTER lol. Thanks alot for sharing
I missed it all...Lovely letter, right from my heart...more kleenex please...was ill...but will catch up...ended on a good note though yesssss...G-Ma :O) Hugs & Peace
That was beautiful Elena and write that article....:)
Why is this lonely tear escaping from my eyes? I need a hug...
I'm okay Elena...thanks for the hugs. I loved reading the letters for it makes me reflect and think and allow all feelings to come. :-) And will do more reading of your hubs this weekend.
thanks for share.I'd love too.great hub
One of my favorite movies of all time is "Shakespeare in Love." If you haven't seen it yet, Elena, then I highly recommend it. By the end of the movie, Gwyneth Paltrow's character Viola, is heartbroken and so asks Queen Elizabeth (played by Judi Dench) "How will this end?" In which Dench replies, "Like with all things, when love is denied--With tears and a journey." Great line.
Elena..what can I say, I heart it! ;p
I wonder what happened next...
Thank you for sharing your feelings. This is another testimony to the power of human bonding. Most all relationships start with the first hello. From that point on we cannot be sure where it will all end, either in happiness or sadness.
I need help writing a love letter. He is my best friend and I have so many times a can remember when he has looked in my eyes or almost held my hand. I dream about what it would be like to be his. I believe we should be together. But whenever I sit down to write it the words leave me brain.






































Frieda Babbley Level 2 Commenter 2 years ago
Have you been reading my diary?